Watch any HGTV House Hunters program and you’ll see home buyer after home buyer walk into a room, take a look at the mouldings, and exclaim…
“Oh my! Look at the mouldings!”
And then the real estate agent says: ”Look at the crown moulding.”
Mouldings can be a beautiful thing.
However, many times they’re not.
Sometimes they’re bulky or puny, cheaply done, outside of the contextual style of the house, and really just don’t make sense.
Don’t let yourself be wowed with the whole “we have wood mouldings” thing. No one in the know is impressed by them being used inappropriately — well, at least, not anyone associated with the construction business.
Most professionals can look at a job with a bunch of wood mouldings and tell you right away if the stuff was slapped up there just to impress someone who doesn’t know any better, or if there was real quality built in to the job.
One dead giveaway: fluted moulding with rosette blocks
Unless you’re rebuilding Tara, or recreating the southern mansion of your dreams, I’m not sure why you would want to put these up in your home. However, around here, they’re everywhere, usually in a version that’s a bit too skinny for the house. In these cases, it has more to do with how easy it is to do a straight cut as opposed to a neat, tidy miter, than anything else.
It also has to do with a builder trying to impress a buyer with all the mouldings. And, really, in a smaller, more run-of-the-mill suburban home, do you really want fluted mouldings and rosette blocks? Doesn’t that read a little unrealistic and over the top? Fussy? Pretentious?
BTW: Here was our updated version while it was in progress ➤
⬅ How about this fireplace mantel?
I think this was designed on site to fit the wall, without regard to scale or anything else, by the carpenter himself.
Here are some general guidelines about mouldings that I use:
Don’t go too big in a small room and don’t go too small in a big space. Mouldings should scale to fit the openings and the room. A 3” wood base moulding in a two story room is going to look chintzy. A 9” wood base moulding in a room with 8’ ceilings is going to look heavy and bulky. By that same token, scale the crown with the base. I often see tiny base mouldings with 12” high crowns. That doesn’t go together. A hefty crown should have a larger scaled base.
STOPPING & STARTING:
Many times crown moulding or a chair rail will run around the room up until the point the wall stops, leaving no place to die the moulding into. This causes the mouldings to just hang there in mid-air, forcing them to turn back into the wall. (Cue several of the examples I showed above.) If you have this situation in your home, maybe you shouldn’t be applying mouldings here at all. Instead, maybe you should celebrate what you’ve got and not force something on a space that doesn’t really belong.
Or perhaps there’s a way to make some other construction tweaks to be able to successfully stop and start your mouldings so the design looks well thought out and purposeful, unlike this seen in the picture to the right. :-(
DESIGN & STYLE:
Always keep in mind the overall style of the house. If you have a transitional style you are wanting to keep throughout the home, keep it lean and less detailed. You might want to consider no crown, a simple base, and door/window framing.
If you have a craftsman-style bungalow, then by all means go all out craftsman with layered mouldings and sharp edges. This look has a clean, crisp style and is heavy on the wood.
If you have a Victorian home, the mouldings are absolutely key here. They telegraph the style of the house.
If you are creating a traditional styled home and like some proportional wood mouldings, then some fluting might be for you. (But please...not at every single door and window casing.) The fireplace might be a good place, or the study at some bookcases, etc.
I typically keep mouldings trim, pretty simple, and scaled appropriately with the space.
I like a clean, neat style that doesn’t make the mouldings the main feature of the room. I like to see homes that focus on the objects and people within — unless, of course, the home’s architectural style is truly enhanced with with focus on the quality mouldings.
Mostly though, I just don’t like fussy for fussy’s sake.